Ian McDonald. The Djinn's Wife.
Originally in : Asimovs, July 2006
When it appeared last year I wrote:
Set in the same near-future AI-heavy Indian milieu of 'The Little Goddess' (Asimovs June 2005), and the novel 'River of Gods', and equally outstanding. McDonald explores the unlikely relationship between an AI, A.J. Rao (who appeared in the novel), and a dancing girl. The AI has fallen for her, and she is flattered to receive the attentions of one such as he. But can true love really happen between woman and AI?
It appears that it can, with the pair relating both emotionally and, surprisingly, physically. But he is an AI who can incorporate many instances of himself, the better to multi-task, and of course a woman can not share a man with others in this way. For her it is all or nothing, and as the rules are changed to make such powerful AI's as he illegal, she has to choose between him and the Krishna cop who wishes to turn him off.
Conclusion.
Last year's anthology from Strahan covered purely science fiction, and as regular readers will know, the SF in Best SF does stand for science fiction, so the inclusion of a number of fantasy stories is bound to weaken a collection as far as I'm concerned. Without getting into too much of an argument over which stories are sf/fantasy/speculative/near-mainstream, it's safe to say that there isn't a whole lot of trad SF in the volume, certainly less than in the Horton volume, and considerably less than in the Hartwell/Cramer volume. (Mind you, I've got the Strahan/Dozois 'The New Space Opera' to hand for a healthy dose of that kind of SF!)
Those writers most readily identified as SF writers provide the goods for the most part, although I'd have skipped the Willis juvenile for any of a number of other stories (possibly R. Garcia y Robertson's 'Kansas, She Says, Is the Name of the Star'), and I would probably have swopped a couple out for other stories (notable omission being William Shunn's 'Inclination').
On the fantasy side, not that I'm an expert on this, but I'd guess that in the same way that Analog readers might not engage with the SF content, those with a preference for the 'traditional' fantasy of the fat fantasy trilogy milieu (with quests, elves, wizards etc) might similarly be disappointed by the primarily contemporary, speculative fiction/horror nature of the 'fantasy' stories in this collection.
For my money, I'd rather separate collections than a combo volume, which leaves this volume satisfying me just a little less than Strahan's previous pure SF anthologies. Now for the fourth and final year's best collection.....
review copyright Mark Watson 26th August 2007