home
reviews | presents | gateway

click to go to index of year's best volumes, else click text link above to go to the main reviews index

The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy of the Year Volume One. ed Jonathan Strahan, Night Shade Books, 2007.

coverscan cover by

US pbk (amazon.com)
UK pbk (amazon.co.uk)

 
clickme Neil Gaiman. How To Talk To Girls At Parties.
clickme Peter S. Beagle El Regalo
clickme Cory Doctorow I Row-Boat
clickme Ellen Klages In The House Of The Seven Librarians.
clickme Christopher Rowe Another Word For Map Is Faith.
clickme Margo Langanan Under Hell, Over Heaven.
clickme Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
clickme Jeffrey Ford. The Night Whiskey.
clickme Benjamin Rosenbaum A Siege Of Cranes.
clickme Frances Hardinge. Halfway House.
clickme Tim Powers The Bible Repairman.
clickme Paolo Bacigalupi The Yellow Card Man.
clickme Geoff Ryman Pol Pot's Beautiful Daughter (Fantasy)
clickme Jay Lake The American Dead.
clickme Robert Charles Wilson The Cartesian Theater.
clickme M. Rickert Journey Into The Kingdom.
clickme Robert Reed Eight Episodes.
clickme Kelly Link The Wizards of Perfil.
clickme Elizabeth Hand The Saffron Gatherers
clickme Connie Willis D.A.
clickme Paul Di Filippo Femaville 29.
clickme Gene Wolfe. Sob In The Silence.
clickme Benjamin Rosenbaum The House Beyond Your Sky.
clickme Ian McDonald The Djinn's Wife.

Out for some months, but finally read by myself (including some restful evenings in a cottage by the Cornish coast), is Jonathan Strahan's latest take on the year's best in short SF and (for this volume) fantasy. Last year he had 'Science Fiction : the Very Best of 2005', which filled a gap left by the demise of the ibooks series, of which he had co-edited 'Science Fiction : The Best of 2004' and '2003'. He's also had a couple of anthologies published by the Science Fiction Book Club, which are only available to members in the USA, but the good news is that after the 'Best Short Novels 2005' and 'Best Short Novels 2006', the 2007 volume is likely to see the light of day to a broader audience, through Prime Books on 1st Sept 2007.

So, having read two of the four annual anthologies so far this year (the Hartwell/Cramer and Horton volumes), what of this handsome, substantial book that looks more like a Dozois annual collection?

Neil Gaiman. How To Talk To Girls At Parties.
Originally in : Fragile Things: Short Fictions and Wonders. ed Morrow.

This neat little story was reprinted in F&SF Jan 2007, whence I wrote:

Peter S. Beagle. El Regalo.
Originally in : Fantasy & Science Fiction, Oct/Nov 2006

When it appeared last year I summarised thus :

In the summary of the issue of F&SF in which it appeared I noted that 'Emshwiller, Bacigalupi and Ryman', and thus, by ommission, Beagle did not excel. As a contemporary magic/juju/fantasy it failed to grab.

Cory Doctorow. I Row-Boat.
Originally in : Flurb : a Webzine of Astonishing Tales. [
available online ]

Don't let the wincing pun put you off - this is a clever little tale of a boat who has, like many previously inanimate objects, achieved sentience in a world suddenly much emptier since large numbers of humans achieved a personal virtual rapture. For the record, it's the second consecutive year a story by Doctor(ow), riffing on The Good Doctor's I Robot has been chosen by Strahan.

Ellen Klages. In The House Of The Seven Librarians.
Originally in : Firebirds Rising. ed November.

I'm a little biased, being a librarian myself, but this is a charming fantasy involving a young baby dropped off at the library in a wicker basket in lieue of a fine. The librarians and the Carnegie library in which they have worked for some time, withdraw into their own peculiar existence, the townspeople having headed off the the shiny new computer-equipped knowledge centre. As in such fantasies, the young girl grows up and as she reaches maturity has to decide whether the big wide world, and a university, will lead her to leave behind her foster mothers.

Christopher Rowe. Another Word For Map Is Faith.
Originally in : F&SF August 2008

When it appeared last year I wrote :

Well, so far Strahan and Horton picked it, but not Hartwell. Will Dozois pick it and have me 3/4?

Margo Langanan. Under Hell, Over Heaven.
Originally in : Red Spikes

A dreadful (as in full of dread rather than poor) tale of a workcrew in the Christian purgatory, who are tasked to ferry one unfortunate soul to the lower place. Langan quite convincingly captures the evanescent joy of a glimpse of heaven, and the truly horrific broiling sulphuric place that is hell.

Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
Originally in : Escape from Earth

This was collected by Horton as well, and when reading it there I wrote:

Jeffrey Ford. The Night Whiskey.
Originally in : Salon Fantastique ed Datlow/Windling.

Another strong story from Ford, describing vividly a remote rural community who have an annual get together which involves the drinking a fermented concoction from a very strange plant. Those few who get the chance to partake of the drink, through a lottery, end up being found the following morning sitting in the lower branches of trees. A young boy is chosen to assist the old man whose job it is to retrieve the tree-dwellers, but this time round one of them comes back with a memento of his nocturnal trip....

It's a story to stick in the mind for some time - in some dark recess, liable to pop up, unannounced and unwanted, at the most inopportune time. It has the feel of a folk tale, of a night time campfire around which campers regale each other with horror stories in the dark oh the dark, and one person comes out with a story which has just that ring of truth about it.

Benjamin Rosenbaum. A Siege Of Cranes.
Originally in : Twenty Epics (All Star Stories) ed Moles & Groppi.

Rosenbaum is putting together a strong series of stories at the beginning of what promises to be a substantial career. This is the first of two stories by him in this year's Strahan volume, in which a trail of devastation is being left across the countryside, small villages and villagers consumed and subsumed in a nightmarish monstrous chariot of flailing body parts.

One villager is set on avenging the murder of his family, and in this he is aided by a jackal-like creature, whose views on the nature of death are at odds with his own.

It's a memorable story, with a touch of the Gene Wolfe's, in that not all in the narrative is explained, and you get a feeling of a glimpse of a much bigger story.

Frances Hardinge. Halfway House.
Originally in : Alchemy 3

A young man on a train finds a world adjacent to his own, accessible by a rural train platform. A young girl has been handed to the boy Kaiser, and we follow the strange grouping as the man gives up a lot of that which was weighing him down, to prevent Wolf getting the the girl, now named Ticket.

Tim Powers. The Bible Repairman.
Originally in : The Bible Repairman

Powers' only other appearance on BestSF was in Dozois' 4th Annual Collection, way back from 1987. Other than that he's been off my radar. This is a short, slightly off-kilter story, in which there is a trade in kidnapped souls, and their restoration. The titular character, in addition to exorcising unwanted phrases from bibles, has a track record in rescuing such souls, although he was unable to do so for his own child. A form of redemption is duly offered.

Paolo Bacigalupi. The Yellow Card Man.
Originally in : Asimovs, December 2006

When it appeared last year I wrote:

Geoff Ryman. Pol Pot's Beautiful Daughter (Fantasy).
Originally in : Fantasy & Science Fiction,

Last year I wrote:

Jay Lake. The American Dead.
Originally in : Interzone 203, March/April 2006

When it appeared last year I wrote:

Robert Charles Wilson. The Cartesian Theater.
Originally in : Futureshocks ed Anders

I read this in this year's Horton collection and said:

M. Rickert. Journey Into The Kingdom.
Originally in : F&SF May 2006

I briefly wrote last year:

Robert Reed. Eight Episodes.
Originally in : Asimovs, June 2006

When reading it last year :

Kelly Link. The Wizards of Perfil.
Originally in : Firebirds Rising ed November

A young girl, fleeing with many others from the approaching war, is taken on as a wizard's apprentice. The wizards of Perfil live monastic, unseen lives atop ivory towers. We follow the young girl's attempts to fulfil the role required of her, which may in fact be somewhat different.

Elizabeth Hand. The Saffron Gatherers.
Originally in : Strange Stories

Editor Strahan points out in the intro that it is hand at her best, with a story which is on the brink of science fiction, fantasy and mainstream. For my money it's some way off science fiction and fantasy, and whilst it is vividly written in terms of bringing the characters to life, just lacks that little something special for me.

Connie Willis. D.A.
Originally in : Space Cadets ed Resnick

A story, as the intro explains, very much in the vein of the young adult novels of Heinlein. I've fond memories of several of those, which I read 30+ years ago, and had I read this story then I doubtless would have got full value for it. As it was I'm obviously too distant from that youthful self to have been willing to overlook the juvenile stylistic/plot issues. No surprise, I suppose, as I didn't get more than a page into the Harry Potter books before giving up.

Paul Di Filippo Femaville 29.
Originally in : Salon Fantastique ed Datlow/Windling

Following the devastation wreaked (wrocked/wroken/wreaken?) by a tsunami on an East Coast city, a young man coming to terms with the situation finds a relationship with a young woman and her daughter helps matters. The daughter is a leading light in an increasingly complex game in which the children in the refugee camp in which they are based begin to map out an alternative city.

It transpires that the youthful hopes of these innocents may lead them to...

Gene Wolfe. Sob In The Silence.
Originally in : Strange Birds

A more straightforward horror story than you might expect from Wolfe. A horror writer has guests at his mansion, and we follow his devious and deviant, and successful, plan to kidnap on of the young women, and hide her, Silence of the Lambs-like, in a nearby well. You would think, though, that a horror story writer would know not to follow his victim down the well......

Benjamin Rosenbaum. The House Beyond Your Sky.
Originally in : Strange Horizons - and
and still online

Also included by Horton this year, and upon reading this in that collection :

    Horton does in his intro make clear that he has an intention to showcase new writers, and Rosenbaum is one such who has made a strong start to his writing career. This is a clever story, which shows a willingness to open up a story to some big concepts, but not to go too far. You can read it online (follow the link above) - it's a short story, and well worth it, although it's a thoughtful piece rather than offering a dramatic narrative.

    And there's a mini discussion on Strange Horizons in which the story is discussed, with a contribution by Rosenbaum. And for those who like your written science fiction squirted into your brain via the earhole, it is also available as a podcast. Having been made available in written and spoken form on a digital basis, it's good to see it on slices of dead-tree and put into Bio Optic Organised Knowledge Source and thus brought to a larger audience.

Ian McDonald. The Djinn's Wife.
Originally in : Asimovs, July 2006

When it appeared last year I wrote:

Conclusion.

Last year's anthology from Strahan covered purely science fiction, and as regular readers will know, the SF in Best SF does stand for science fiction, so the inclusion of a number of fantasy stories is bound to weaken a collection as far as I'm concerned. Without getting into too much of an argument over which stories are sf/fantasy/speculative/near-mainstream, it's safe to say that there isn't a whole lot of trad SF in the volume, certainly less than in the Horton volume, and considerably less than in the Hartwell/Cramer volume. (Mind you, I've got the Strahan/Dozois 'The New Space Opera' to hand for a healthy dose of that kind of SF!)

Those writers most readily identified as SF writers provide the goods for the most part, although I'd have skipped the Willis juvenile for any of a number of other stories (possibly R. Garcia y Robertson's 'Kansas, She Says, Is the Name of the Star'), and I would probably have swopped a couple out for other stories (notable omission being William Shunn's 'Inclination').

On the fantasy side, not that I'm an expert on this, but I'd guess that in the same way that Analog readers might not engage with the SF content, those with a preference for the 'traditional' fantasy of the fat fantasy trilogy milieu (with quests, elves, wizards etc) might similarly be disappointed by the primarily contemporary, speculative fiction/horror nature of the 'fantasy' stories in this collection.

For my money, I'd rather separate collections than a combo volume, which leaves this volume satisfying me just a little less than Strahan's previous pure SF anthologies. Now for the fourth and final year's best collection.....

review copyright Mark Watson 26th August 2007