Science Fiction Book Club Best Short Novels 2005, ed Jonathan Strahan, SFBC 2005.

clickme James Patrick Kelly Men Are Trouble
clickme Stephen Baxter Mayflower II
clickme Bradley Denton Sergeant Chip
clickme Eleanor Arnason The Garden : a Hwarhath Science Fictional Romance
clickme Ian McDowell Under the Flag of Night
clickme Gardner Dozois, George RR Martin, Daniel Abraham Shadow Twin
clickme Charles Stross The Concrete Jungle
clickme Patricia A McKillip The Gorgon in the Cupboard
clickme Judith Berman The Fear Gun
clickme Gregory Feeley Arabian Wine
click yellow buttons to jump to specific stories, else scroll down for reviews.

There have been three Year's Best SF collections vying for our attention for some years now, with the Dozois Annual Collection halfway through its third decade, and two smaller volumes, Hartwell/Kramer's Years Best SF starting its second decade, with the newcomer, Haber/Strahan's 'Science Fiction : The Best of' are mere toddler at only five years of age.

The volume in hand is the second in a further series, from the Science Fiction Book Club (SFBC website), and available only to members of the club (membership being limited to those in the States). This new series, covers, as you might expect from the title, novellas, and is an interesing echo for those with long memories, of a previous attempt to address this niche by Terry Carr, who had two attempts at a novella collection alongside his own successful annual collection of short stories.

The almost 600 pages contains ten lengthy stories, and may well attract some of the large number of readers of SF novels who appear unwilling/unable/uninterested in reading the shorter form.

As is my well established wont, I shall run through the stories in the order in which they appear

James Patrick Kelly. Men Are Trouble.
Originally in : Asimovs, June 2004

When I reviewed this in its original magazine appearance I was quite fulsome :

Stephen Baxter. Mayflower II.
Originally in : chapbook of the same name, PS Publishing.

When it first appeared I wrote:

Well, it did appear in Dozois 22nd, as well as this volume.

Bradley Denton. Sergeant Chip.
Originally in : F&SF, September 2004

Another story I read first time round in its magazine appearance

Eleanor Arnason. The Garden : a Hwarhath Science Fictional Romance.
Originally in : Synergy SF: New Science Fiction (ed Zebrowski)

I'm obviously in a minority with this story, as it was also collected in Dozois' 22nd Annual Collection. Having read it, I wrote, somewhat abruptly(!)

    I've had a dig at Arnason - before - and as she has retread the aforelinked story I'm going to retread my criticisms. The previous story had protagonists who were humans in every nuance, other than not being human and being furry. The previous story had furry sappho couplings, and here we have furry man on man lurve. Oh really, I can't be bothered to go any further with this review, life's way too short.

Ian McDowell. Under the Flag of Night.
Originally in : Asimovs, March 2004.

When it originally appeared I wrote :

I have to own up to my idea of SF not being sufficiently broad church to cover ghostly piratical stories!

Gardner Dozois, George RR Martin, Daniel Abraham. Shadow Twin.
Originally in SCI FICTION, 2004

I didn't review the story after reading it online in SCI FICTION, but did so when it turned up again in Asimovs the following year

Worthy of note, although I don't have the source to hand, is the history of this story, which was started by Dozois in the 70s, picked up by Martin a decade later, and finally finished by Abraham more recently.

It's still online on the SCI FICTION site - or at least will be until those bastids at the SCI FI Channel take down the no longer updated SCI FICTION (that excellent, nay world-class, site mothballed so that they can invest the money is the almost uniformly dire multimedia SF pap they do : I'd moth their balls if I got my hands on them)

Charles Stross. The Concrete Jungle.
Originally in : The Atrocity Archives, 2004

The short novel The Atrocity Archives appeared in Spectrum SF issues 8-10, introducing to the work of the very lowkey British secret service setup 'The Laundry', who specialise in subduing the eldritch horrors, and their very un-Bond-like Bob Howard. 'The Concrete Journal' followup doesn't quite hit the peaks of that first story, but memorably starts with exploding concrete cows in Milton Keynes, and finishes with the gibbering horrors back at HQ.

A further Laundry story appears in the recently launched Jim Baen's Universe.

Patricia A. McKillip. The Gorgon in the Cupboard.
Originally in : To Weave a Web of Magic.

A fantasy of the type which features quite regularly in The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, and for my money, there must have been a number of more inventive fantasies that this one, which for me is just too cod-fantasy for my liking. That is to say, fantasy settings that aren't particularly fantastical, but rather set in a vaguely medieval type background. The story revolves around an artist, his muse, a painting which talks, but didn't grab me at all.

Judith Berman. The Fear Gun.
Originally in : Asimovs, July 2004.

When it originally appeared I wrote :

Gregory Feeley. Arabian Wine.
Originally in : Asimovs April/May 2004

When it appears I was somewhat underwhelmed and wrote:

Conclusion.

An impressive collection in terms of meeting my idea of what is best in SF, although it is worth noting that those that least grabbed me were clearly the least sfnal in the collection. For my money I'd replace those non-Science Fiction stories with some 'proper' SF, such as Christopher Rowe's 'The Voluntary State', or Nancy Kress' 'Shiva in Shadow', but that would leave such a collection suiting die-hard hardish-SF bods like me rather than the wider SF audience, so I'll bow to Strahan's editorial judgement and give him (like he gives a damn) a big thumbs up.

copyright Mark Watson 22nd March 2006