reviews

Nebula Awards Showcase 2005 - edited by Jack Dann, Roc, March 2005.

coverscan
US pbk (amazon.com)
UK pbk (amazon.co.uk)
 
clickme Richard Bowes. The Mask of the Rex
clickme James Van Pelt. Last of the O-Forms.
clickme Carol Emshwiller Grandma
clickme Molly Gloss Lambing Season
clickme Cory Doctorow 0wnz0red
clickme Eleanor Arnason Knapsack Poems
clickme Karen Joy Fowler What I Didn't See
clickme Adam Troy-Castro Of a Sweet Slow Dance in the Wake of Temporary Dogs
clickme Harlan Ellison Goodbye to All That
clickme Jeffrey Ford The Empire of Ice Cream

Jack Dann picks up the editorial reins from Vonda N. McIntyre in the Nebula Awards Showcase series. There's a lot of high quality fiction in this volume, and the only real beef is that the stories are from 2002, which means that in a number of cases you are reading stories which appeared in the Year's Best anthologies two years ago.

After a short introduction and listing of the awards, the fiction gets underway, with relatively lengthy author introductions, which really gives added value to the volume. Richard Bowes 'The Mask of the Rex' first appeared in Fantasy & Science Fiction May 2002. When reviewing it in its original publication I wrote :

The story was a runner up in the novelette category.

James Van Pelt's 'The Last of the O'Forms' appeared in Asimovs in 2002, and I received it thus :

In 'Movements in Science Fiction and Fantasy : A Symposium' Bruce Sterling, China Mieville, Paul McAuley, Ellen Kushner and Jeff Vandermeer provide commentary on various aspects of SF.

Carol Emshwiller's 'Grandma' appeared in Fantasy & Science Fiction March 2002, and appeared in Hartwell's 'Years Best #6', and I wasn't overly impressed, stating "In a recent On Spec we saw Superman as being adopted by a Canadian Jewish family. Here the super/wonder woman is in her dotage, her superhero days long gone."

Barry Malzberg pays a short tribute to Grand Master Robert Silverberg, whose story 'Sundance' is reprinted.

Molly Gloss' 'Lambing Season' appeared in Asimovs in July 2002, and collected in Dozois 20th, and I reviewed it :

Cory Doctorow's 'Ownzored' appeared in Salon.Com in August 2002, and was the first of the stories in this volume which I hadn't previously read, an omission I was pleased to be able to rectify.

Murray Swain is not having a happy time at work in his Silicon Valley job, and the only question is whether a breakdown or loss of employment is going to hit first. Watching his best friend fade away and die has been a bummer, and he is more than a little surprised when Liam is waiting for him in the car park. Liam is in the rudest of health, and Murray finds out that Liam has been the beneficiary of some very interesting DNA-dabbling by the military, which got him back on his feet at the very last minute. Liam is contagious - but the contagion is one that gives the infected person more control over their body's natural processes than could be dreamt of. The question is how the two of them are going to make use of this ability.

An intriguing story, although for my money it tails off a little at the end.

Following Lucius Shepard's review of the year in films, Elearnor Arnason's 'Knapsack Poems', orginally in Asimovs, May 2002

One major disappointment for this volume is that we don't see Neil Gaiman's Coraline in full, and the Best Novella Winner is only available in extract format. So I for one have yet to read it!

Not only available in this volume, but still online at SCI FICTION, is the Best Short Story Winner - Karen Joy Fowler's 'What I Didn't See'. The introduction to the story is fascinating, describing the links to 'Alice Sheldon/James Tiptree Jr' and her story 'The Women Men Don't See'. Fowler's story is of a similar standard, although lacking any SFnal elements in the story itself!

Barry N Malzberg's 'Tripping with the Alchemist' appeared in Fantasy and Science Fiction, June 2003, an autobiographical essay. I'm not sure at the moment as to why it's in this volume?

George Zebrowski pays tribute to Author Emeritus Charles L. Harness, whose alternate history story 'Quarks at Appomattox' is reprinted. I'm not a big fan of AH a the best of times, and being British a story set at a crucial time on the American Civil War is not going to resonate in any way, so I'm rather left with a feeling of 'so what' as opposed to 'what if'.

Adam-Troy Castro's 'Of a Sweet Slow Dance in the Wake of Temporary Dogs' lulls the reader with its tale of beauty and love, AND THEN LETS LOOSE THE DOGS OF WAR! In a bravura piece of writing, there is an unsettling shift from an idyllic setting into noise, death, destruction, horror, horror and more horror as the grotesque SFnal conceit is brought into action. For the days of beauty and love are numbered - nine. And the price for those days are a single day of horror and mutilation, pain and death, before another nine days of beauty begin again, everyone restored to health. And for those living in that strange land it is a price which is paid willingly, but in silence.

The story appeared first in Imaginings in 2003, and its appearance in this volume will bring it to a deserved wider audience. The fact that the author cites this as 'his 9/11' story gives added resonance to the story.

Harlan Ellison's 'Goodbye to All That' first appeared in McSweeney's Mammoth Treasury of Thrilling Tales', and is okay, but not worthy of a nomination IMHO. If you err on the side of finding Ellison a 'professional blowhard' (link) you will doubtless find the lengthy intro and the story itself irritates worse than a rectal itch in a job interview.

Jeffrey Ford's 'Empire of Ice Cream' was Best Novelette and when reading it in Haber/Strahan's Science Fiction : the Best of 2003, I merely noted it was 'smooth'. You can read a much more erudite review here! You can read the synethesic story online at SCI FICTION

You can compare the contents of this volume with the take on the best for 2002 in the shape of Dozois' 20th, Hartwell's 8th, and Silverberg/Haber's 2002. For details of the winners/nominees I would refer you to LocusMag Index to Awards for the Nebula Awards, and the Hugo Awards for the matching year.

review copyright Mark Watson 26th May 2005