home
reviews | presents | gateway

year's best

Science Fiction The Best of the Year 2007 edition, ed Rich Horton, Prime Books 2007.

quantum Earth edition with different content!
US pbk (amazon.com)
UK pbk (amazon.co.uk)
click yellow buttons to jump to specific stories, else scroll down for reviews.
clickme Christopher Rowe. Another Word for Map is Faith.
clickme Carolyn Ives Gilman. Okanoggan Falls.
clickme Ian Watson. Saving for a Sunny Day.
clickme Robert Charles Wilson. The Cartesian Theater.
clickme Ann Leckie Hesperia and Glory.
clickme Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
clickme Ruth Nestvold. Exit Before Saving.
clickme William Shunn. Inclination.
clickme Jack Skillingstead. Life on the Preservation.
clickme Adam Roberts. Me-topia.
clickme Benjamin Rosenbaum. The House Beyond Your Sky.
clickme Robert Reed. A Billion Eves.

Hard on the heels of reviewing Hartwell/Cramer's #12, is Horton's second volume with his take on the Year's Bests. Last year I noted that Horton's volume had more 'misses' than 'hits', so what of this year? Seven of the twelve in the volume I'm already familiar with, and I concur with pretty much all of them, which is quite a contrast to last year, where there were a few I'd previously read which I couldn't agree with. So, in order in which they appear ....

Christopher Rowe. Another Word for Map is Faith.
Originally in : Fantasy & Science Fiction, August 2006

When I read this last year I wrote:

Good to start the volume off with one with which both Horton and I share the same view!

Carolyn Ives Gilman. Okanoggan Falls.
Originally in : Fantasy & Science Fiction, August 2006

In the same issue of F&SF as the previous story, the review of said magazine of which I noted that Rowe and Gilman 'bring that something special', I wrote of this L

Although fair to say, the story doesn't leap from memory like many others during the year.

Ian Watson. Saving for a Sunny Day.
Originally in : Asimovs, Oct/Nov 2006

In the review of Hartwell's #12th, I noted that the two double-issues of Asimovs could be put together in a new cover as published as a Year's Best, so good were they. This is one of the stories frome one of those issues, and I summarised it thus:

Although, as with the previous story, not one that at the time struck me as being of the very top ilk.

Robert Charles Wilson. The Cartesian Theater.
Originally in Futureshocks ed Lou Anders

A very clever piece from a collection which I didn't quite get around to getting a hold of (Anders' previous anthology, Live Without a Net, was excellent).

Wilson uses technology to make virtual the Cartesian soul. A couple of centuries hence a somewhat unpleasant performance artiste demonstrate how he can use hi-tech to substantiate a copy of a living creature, out of nano-gel. Having created a canine doppelganger, it lives for a few minutes before it starts to decohere.

The next step is to copy himself, and to set up a chillingly bizarre piece of theatre in which both he and his temporary twin will wait to see which of the two is the version which will not live long.

There is a neat twist in the tail as to who exactly is pulling the strings, the better to explore the nature of intelligence, humanity, and the soul, in creatures not of flesh and blood.

Ann Leckie. Hesperia and Glory.
Originally in : Subterranean Magazine

Leckie pays a tongue-in-cheek homage to ERB and Barsoom, in a tale of a Martian prince who finds himself likely stranded on Earth. He relates the challenges he faced back on his home planet, in which mind-power holds ultimate sway, and the fears he has that his Mars may not be there for him to return. Last year Horton chose Susan Palwick's 'Fate of Mice' which nodded vigorously in the direction of another SF classic. I can see the attraction of doing this in a big collection, but with only a limited amount of space, this might be just too much of a luxury.

Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
Originally in : Escape from Earth

A strong story from Williams, as tends to be the case. He posits an intriguing background - a society in which many parents choose to raise their children as virtual ones - a sort of tamagochi - until such time as they, in their mid-teens, are ready to be encoded into a living, vat-grown, teen body. As virtual constructs, the children are able to develop virtually 24/7, and have their coded selves squirted across space.

We follow a group of virtual sibs, a cadre, who are approaching their Incarnation Day, and what appears initially to be an adventure story surrounding them, becomes much darker as the strains between one young woman and her mother develop into a life-threatening situation, as the parents have the right to return their virtual children to a zero state, and start again.

Ruth Nestvold. Exit Before Saving.
Originally in : Futurismic

Mallory is a hi-tech agent who 'morphs' - has herself uploaded into another body, the better to carry out industrial espionage. It's somewhat unfeasibly hi-tech, and the story feels like a fairly low-rent TV scifi drama. A long way from a Year's Best imho.

William Shunn. Inclination.
Originally in : Asimovs, Apr/May 2006

This would be one of the first stories to go into my Year's Best, and I summarised last year :

Jack Skillingstead. Life on the Preservation.
Originally in : Asimovs, June 2006

When it appeared last year I wrote:

Adam Roberts. Me-topia.
Originally in : Forbidden Planet, ed Pete Crowther

When this appeared in one of the couple of original anthologies I read last year I said:

Benjamin Rosenbaum. The House Beyond Your Sky.
Originally in : Strange Horizons
- and
and still online

Horton does in his intro make clear that he has an intention to showcase new writers, and Rosenbaum is one such who has made a strong start to his writing career. This is a clever story, which shows a willingness to open up a story to some big concepts, but not to go too far. You can read it online (follow the link above) - it's a short story, and well worth it, although it's a thoughtful piece rather than offering a dramatic narrative.

And there's a mini discussion on Strange Horizons in which the story is discussed, with a contribution by Rosenbaum. And for those who like your written science fiction squirted into your brain via the earhole, it is also available as a podcast. Having been made available in written and spoken form on a digital basis, it's good to see it on slices of dead-tree and put into Bio Optic Organised Knowledge Source and thus brought to a larger audience.

Robert Reed. A Billion Eves.
Originally in : Asimovs, Oct/Nov 2006

Last year I wrote:

Conclusion.

A collection more in tune with my preferences than last year's, with the exclusion of Analog stories being the primary cause of that. Interestingly, Horton picked three stories which I had indicated that Hartwell's 12th could/should have included (the Shunn, Reed and Rowe stories). It's a good collection, albeit with a couple of weak stories, and I'm tempted to rate this above the Hartwell collection, despite that volume having more stories, as there are more top quality stories in the Horton collection.

In terms of bang for buck I'm expecting a good deal from the forthcoming Strahan and Dozois collections. In the meantime, I'm off to explore the quantum branes to find the world in which this volume included stories by Haldeman, Reynolds and Swanwick. The cover of the book has obviously leaked into Amazon-space in this brane, as evidenced by the cover picture above....

copyright Mark Watson 7th July 2007

BestSF home