home
reviews | presents | gateway

year's best

Year's Best Science Fiction, 24th Annual Collection. Gardner Dozois. St. Martins Griffin, 2007.

early Amazon cover
US pbk (amazon.com)
UK pbk (amazon.co.uk)
click yellow buttons to jump to specific stories, else scroll down for reviews.
clickme Cory Doctorow. I, Row-Boat.
clickme Robert Charles Wilson. Julian : a Christmas Story.
clickme Michael Swanwick. Tin Marsh.
clickme Ian McDonald. The Djinn's Wife.
clickme Benjamin Rosenbaum. The House Beyond Your Sky.
clickme Kage Baker. Where the Golden Apples Grow.
clickme Bruce McAllister. Kin.
clickme Alastair Reynolds. Signal to Noise.
clickme Jay Lake and Ruth Nestvold. The Big Ice.
clickme Gregory Benford. Bow Shock.
clickme Justin Stanchfield. In the River.
clickme Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
clickme Greg Van Eekhout. Far as YOu Can Go.
clickme Robert Reed. Good Mountain.
clickme David D. Levine. I Hold My Father's Paws.
clickme Paul J. McAuley. Dead Men Walking.
clickme Mary Rosenblum. Home Movies.
clickme Daryl Gregory. Damascus.
clickme Jack Skillingstead. Life on the Preservation.
clickme Paolo Bacigalupi. Yellow Card Man.
clickme Greg Egan. Riding the Crocodile.
clickme Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette. The Ile of Dogges.
clickme Ken MacLeod. The Highway Men.
clickme Stephen Baxter. The Pacific Mystery.
clickme Carolyn Ives Gilman. Okanoggan Falls.
clickme John Barnes. Every Hole is Outlined.
clickme A.M. Dellamonica. The Town on Blighted Sea.
clickme Alastair Reynolds. Nightingale.

It's taken me some time to get round to reviewing the 24th Annual Collection. I did read it last summer, but didn't get round to writing it up. One good thing about the delay is that those stories I read for the first time last year, I've had to re-read for the purposes of writing the reviews! So, what of #24???

Cory Doctorow. I, Row-Boat.
Originally in : Flurb 1, Fall 2006.

When I read it in Strahan's take on the best of the year, I wrote:

Robert Charles Wilson. Julian : a Christmas Story.
Originally in : Julian: a Christmas Story, PS Publishing 2006.

Set in 2172 in an America much changed, many years after the Years of Vice and Profligacy which saw oil run reserves run out, and which led to the Days of False Tribulation, when war, famine and the consequent depopulation suggested that the day of judgment was at hand.

The narrator, Adam, is looking back many years, in providing the story of himself and Julian at age 17, and the references to future events and previous events gives a robuts three-dimensionality to it, in contrast to many stories which simple relate the specific incidents which happen during the course of the events described. The secular society of the 20th and 21st centuries has been replaced by a religious one in which the Dominion certifies churches of all christian denomination, including the Catholic Church of America, which has forsworn its fealty to Rome. It is a conservative world, harking back to the simpler times of the 19th Century. There is a strict class stratification : with aristos, the leasing class, and indentured labourers. Adam, is from the leasing class, but is the companion of the aristo Julian, whose father, brother to the President, has been hung for treachery - although it appears that he was deemed a threat by a fratricidal President.

The story begins with a visit to the Tip - the place were material scavenged from the old cities are brought, and Adam picks up a book, which are in short supply, especially those without the seal of approval of The Dominion. The book he picks up is a history of mankind in space, but in the world he lives such suggestions, along with Darwinism, and philosophy are not tolerated. With war looming, conscription is rearing its ugly head, and young Julian fears that his uncle may see this as a way to rid himself of another threat.

It's a subtle, very well rounded story, clearly part of a bigger work.

Michael Swanwick. Tin Marsh.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, August 2006.

When it appeared in its original magazine appearance I wrote:

Also collected by Hartwell/Cramer in their taken on the best of 2006.

Ian McDonald. The Djinn's Wife.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, July 2006

When reading it originally I wrote:

Again, also chosed by Strahan this year.

Benjamin Rosenbaum. The House Beyond Your Sky.
Originally in : Strange Horizons, 4 Sept 2006.
and still online

Collected not only by Dozois, but also by Strahan and Horton, and in my first reading of this story in the Horton anthology I wrote:

    Horton does in his intro make clear that he has an intention to showcase new writers, and Rosenbaum is one such who has made a strong start to his writing career. This is a clever story, which shows a willingness to open up a story to some big concepts, but not to go too far. You can read it online (follow the link above) - it's a short story, and well worth it, although it's a thoughtful piece rather than offering a dramatic narrative.

    And there's a mini discussion on Strange Horizons in which the story is discussed, with a contribution by Rosenbaum. And for those who like your written science fiction squirted into your brain via the earhole, it is also available as a podcast. Having been made available in written and spoken form on a digital basis, it's good to see it on slices of dead-tree and put into Bio Optic Organised Knowledge Source and thus brought to a larger audience

Kage Baker. Where the Golden Apples Grow.
Originally in : Escape from the Earth (SFBC)

Two young boys on Mars get a chance to see an alternative to their life : one, feeling claustrophobic in the narrow agricultural confines of the Collective; the other for whom the wide open spaces of the Martian surface in the cab of his father's hauler offer little to him. The two come together and there is a dramatic life or death denouement.

OK as far as it goes, but without anything leaping out at this reader as being substantially different from a lot of similar stories over several decades.

Bruce McAllister. Kin.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, February 2006.

On its original appearance I wrote:

Alastair Reynolds. Signal to Noise.
Originally in : Zima Blue and Other Stories.

This story was a new one in a collection of Reynold's published last year, and upon reading it then I wrote:

Jay Lake and Ruth Nestvold. The Big Ice.
Originally in : Jim Baen's Universe, no 4, December 2006.

Two planetologists on Hutchinson's World, one of over three hundred planets on which Core has moved humanity, should be of little concern to the political plotting and coups - except that one of them is the sister of a leading player in one of the political famillies.

The Big Ice is a huge remnant impact crater, which should by rights have destroyed the planet. The crater is ice-bound, and deep in the icy depths are biologicals that sould not be present, which do not appear to tie in with the panspermic biology on other planets. Alicia finds out just how strange the biology is when, having been left for dead by her brother, her own hi-tech inbuilt survival mechanisms sees her take on that biology to survive. The result is a fearsome killing creature.

It's an interesting setup, a sort of Dune on ice, and craves a much bigger canvas - imagine Herbert's Dune finishing after just a half dozen pages!

Gregory Benford. Bow Shock.
Originally in : Jim Baen's Universe, no. 1, June 2006.

I tend to find the scientist fiction that appears in Analog leaves me cold, whereas Benford's scientist fiction generally grabs, and this is the case here. Very much in the Diagrams Supplied mode, we follow a young scientist struggling to get tenure, an old student friend getting the headlines, and coming close to stealing some of his ideas.

The nature of the runaway neturon star he and his rival scientist have been studying comes under scrutiny, and in the final paragaphs we find out exactly what the hypothesis is - the data and the representation of that data point to us being witness to the death throes of an interplanetary spaceship.

Justin Stanchfield. In the River.
Originally in : Interzone, August 2006.

When it appeared in its original magazine publication, which had until then not had a whole lot of SF int he issue, I wrote:

Walter Jon Williams. Incarnation Day.
Originally in : Escape from Earth, SFBC 2006.

Also collected by both Horton and Strahan, I wrote of this :

Greg Van Eekhout. Far as You can Go.
Originally in : Show and Tell and Other Stories.

A young boy living very much on the wrong side of the tracks has a beat-up robot as a companion, and having caught a momentary whiff of the distant, fresh sea, the boy finds Beeman willing to show him the way out of the scavenging life he has.

Robert Reed. Good Mountain.
Originally in : One Million AD (SFBC)

When it appeared in the Dozois edited far-future anthology (which boggled me less than I had been hoping) I wrote:

David D. Levine. I Hold My Father's Paws.
Originally in : Albedo One, no 31, June 2006.

The latest craze is for people to have surgery to change their species, and when a young man finds out that his estranged father is to go under the surgeon's knife, he visits in order to understand why his father wants to become a canine, and why he left the family years ago. It transpires that the two are linked - the father feels unable to give unconditional love as a human and believes as a dog he can.

It's one of the weaker stories in the volume, built on a rather unbelievable premise.

Paul J. McAuley. Dead Men Walking.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, March 2006.

Also picked by Hartwell/Cramer, and when it first I appeared my musings were thus :

Mary Rosenblum. Home Movies.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, April/May 2006.

When it first appeared I wroted :

Also chosen by Hartwell/Cramer this year.

Daryl Gregory. Damascus.
Originally in : The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, December 2006.

Also Hartwell/Cramered this year, and on its first appearance I wrote:

Jack Skillingstead. Life on the Preservation.
Originally in : Asimov's Science Fiction, June 2006.

Also Hortoned this year, and when it appeared in 'mov's I wrote:

Paolo Bacigalupi. Yellow Card Man.
Originally in : Asimov's December 2006.

Also chosen by Strahan, in its magazine appearance I was impressed :

Greg Egan. Riding the Crocodile.
Originally in : One Million A.D. (SFBC)

The second inclusion from the Dozois-edited boggleLITE collection, of which I wrote:

For me, the Charles Stross was the most memorable of the stories in the original collection.

Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette. The Ile of Dogges.
Originally in : Aeon Seven, August 2006.

Short piece in which a time traveller returns to Elizabethan England to rescue a play lost to history.

Ken MacLeod. The Highway Men.
Originally in : The Highway Men (Sandstone Press)

I gave this one a lengthy review on its original publication.

Stephen Baxter. The Pacific Mystery.
Originally in : The Mammoth Book of Extreme SF

Assured Alternate History from Baxter, who postulates a post-Second World War, with the Allies working with the Nazis on a mission - to circumnavigate the globe. This is a feat yet to be achieved, as the Pacific has yet to be crossed. We follow the diaries written by notes aviatrix Bliss Stirling abord the monstrously large, nuclear-powered battleship Reichsmarschall des Grossdeutschen Reices Hermann Goering as it heads East. And further East. And further still....

Carolyn Ives Gilman. Okanoggan Falls.
Originally in : The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, August 2006.

Noting in the conclusion to the issue of the magazine in which it appeared, that Gilman had provided something 'that bit special' (and Horton also anthologised it), I wrote:

John Barnes. Every Hole is Outlined.
Originally in : Jim Baen's Universe, no. 2, August 2006.

One of the stronger stories in the volume. In a far future, and across vast distances and timescales, Barnes paints a surprisingly tender and touching tale of love across many years. When the senior mathematician of the small eight-person crew loses his partner, the decision is made to recruit a replacement, and young Xhrina is chosen to be Mtepic's partner and junior-mathematician. We follow the pair as he grows older, and the pair witness visitations from ghosts amongst the stars. After his death Xhrina rises to be the ship's captain, and in her dotage she and Mtepic are reunited.

A.M. Dellamonica. The Town on Blighted Sea.
Originally in : Strange Horizons, August 28, 2006.

Alien intervention in the civil war on Earth has led to humanity being despatched to other planets, and in one city, a young human has killed one of the aliens, and needs help from his family and the underground to cover up the deed and to fight another day.

Alastair Reynolds. Nightingale.
Originally in : Galactic North

Reynolds publishes two anthologies last year, and Dozois has picked a story from each. Of this one I said:

Conclusion

As ever, only a couple of stories I would quibble with, and as ever, reason to be grateful that St Martin's Press continue to support the field with a volume of this size.

As a record of the best in short SF in the year, Dozois could stand alone, but also covering this year were Rich Horton's Science Fiction The Best of the Year 2007 Edition, David Hartwell and Kathryn Cramer's Year's Best SF #12, and Jonathan Strahan's The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy of the Year Volume One. Put the four together and that's a lot to be proud of!

Now then, where is Amazon with this year's volumes....

copyright Mark Watson 16th March 2008.