Year's Best Science Fiction, 21st Annual Collection. Gardner Dozois. St. Martins Griffin, 2004.


US pbk (amazon.com)
UK pbk (amazon.co.uk)
click yellow buttons to jump to specific stories, else scroll down for reviews.
clickme William Barton Off on a Starship
clickme John Kessel It's All True
clickme Charles Stross Rogue Farm
clickme Steven Popkes The Ice
clickme Nancy Kress Ej-es
clickme John Varley The Bellman
clickme Judith Moffett The Bear's Baby
clickme Howard Waldrop Calling Your Name
clickme Kristine Kathryn Rusch June Sixteenth at Anna's
clickme Walter Jon Williams The Green Leopard Plague
clickme Paolo Bacigalupi The Fluted Girl
clickme Jack Skillingstead Dead Worlds
clickme Michael Swanwick King Dragon
clickme Paul Melko Singletons in Love
clickme M Shayne Bell Anomalous Structures of My Dreams
clickme Vernor Vinge The Cookie Monster
clickme Harry Turtledove Joe Steele
clickme Geoff Ryman Birth Days
clickme John C Wright Awake in the Night
clickme James van Pelt The Long Way Home
clickme Geoffrey A Landis The Eyes of America
clickme Kage Baker Welcome to Olympus, Mr Hearst
clickme Robert Reed Night of Time
clickme William Shunn Strong Medicine
clickme Dominic Green Send Me a Mentagram
clickme Paul di Filippo And the Dish Ran Away with the Spoon
clickme Terry Dowling Flashmen
clickme Nick DiChario Dragonhead
clickme Terry Bisson Dear Abbey

William Barton. Off on a Starship.
Originally in : Asimovs, September 2003

When I read this in its original magazine appearance I wrote:

John Kessel. It's All True.
Originally in : SCI FICTION, November 2003 -
read it here

Kessel used a plot device which has been used before : people from the future coming back to 'recruit' celebrities, to take them back to their time. I wasn't altogether enthused with the device, probably for the same reasons that I haven't taken to Kage Baker's 'The Company' stories (one of which later), in that they tend to be historical stories rather than SF. What Kessel manages though is the vivid portrayal of Orson Welles, who point blank refuses to take the offer made to him. This means that there's none of the silliness involved in Mr Welles visiting the future and marvelling at 'automobiles that fly' etc.

Charles Stross. Rogue Farm.
Originally in : Live Without a Net, ed Lou Anders 2003

When I read this excellent anthology last year, I reviewed this story thus:

Steven Popkes. The Ice.
Originally in : Asimovs, January 2003

When reviewing it in its orginal magazine appearance I wrote:

Nancy Kress. Ej-es.
Originally in : Stars, ed Janis Ian and Mike Resnick.

I read this in Hartwell/Cramer's Years Best SF #9 and said:

I have to beg to differ on my opinion of the story with Dozois/Hartwell, as the story didn't really grab em.

John Varley. The Bellman.
Originally in : Asimovs, June 2003

When it first appeared I summarized :

Judith Moffett. The Bear's Baby.
Originally in : F&SF October 2003.

When it appeared in its magazine appearance I mused thusly:

Howard Waldrop. Calling Your Name.
Originally in : Stars, ed Janis Ian/Howard Waldrop.

This story was anthologised in this year's 'Science Fiction: The best of 2003' and when reading this story in that Haber/Strahan volume I noted:

Kristine Kathryn Rusch. June Sixteenth at Anna's.
Originally in : Asimovs, April 2003.

When I read this last year I said:

Walter Jon Williams. The Green Leopard Plague.
Originally in : Asimovs, October/November 2003

When it first appeared I wrote :

Paolo Bacigalupi. The Fluted Girl.
Originally in : F&SF June 2003.

On its first appearance I wrote:

Jack Skillingstead. Dead Worlds.
Originally in : Asimovs June 2003

This appared last year, in the same issue as the Varley story above, to which my summary at the time referred:

Michael Swanwick. King Dragon.
Originally in : The Dragon Quintet, SFBC

A Science Fiction Book Club original, set, Dozois informs us, in the author's 'Iron Dragon's Daugher' milieu. A melange of fantasy and SF, in which a near future, previously hi-tech Earth is somehow (this is not explained) also a setting for ancient magicke. In this story a steampunkish dragon made of metal crashes to Earth in the middle of a village, where it exercises its authority as best it can - necessitating the use of a young village boy as its mouthpiece and enforcer.

The story twists and keeps up a strong story in an imaginative setting.

Paul Melko. Singletons in Love.
Originally in : Live Without a Net (ed Lou Anders)

When I read this last year I wrote:

M. Shayne Bell. Anomalous Structures of My Dreams.
Originally in : F&SF January 2003

In its original magazine appearance I wrote :

Vernor Vinge. The Cookie Monster.
Originally in : Analog, October 2003

This story was also collected in Haber/Strahan's best of 2003, but is a story about which I beg to differ with them, Dozois, and many others (it won a Hugo)!

Harry Turtledove. Joe Steele.
Originally in : Stars, ed Janis Ian and Mike Resnick.

An Alternate History - one in which following the Great Depression in the US, a very left of centre politican is elected (in real life at this time there were still socialists and communists were standing for the presidency). And whilst Trotsky has survied in the USSR and Joe Stalin does not come to power, Joe Steele is responsible for a lot of oppression in the name of communism.

I found the story intriguing in the early parts, as the dynamics by which such a person could have come to power are explored, although to my mind the story tails off with the routine 'what ifs..' of Alternate History are explored.

Geoff Ryman. Birth Days.
Originally in : Interzone, April 2003

When I read this originally I wrote :

John C. Wright. Awake in the Night.
Originally in : William Hope Hogdson's Night Lands, Vol 1 : Eternal Love.

A story set in Hope Hodgson's 'Night Lands', a relatively little known Victorian novel. I haven't read the original, but did read one published in Interzone in recent years. The impression that I got from reading that short story, and having a quick look at this one, is that familiarity with the original will immeasurably improve the reading of these tributes/sharecrops.

James van Pelt. The Long Way Home.
Originally in : Asimovs, September 2003

On its original appearance I wrote :

Geoffrey A. Landis. The Eyes of America.
Originally in : SCI FICTION -
read it here

Too close in many ways to the Joe Steele short story for comfort, as far as this anthology is concerned. We are taken back to an Alternate USA at the very beginning of the 20th Century. Landis has great fun with Samuel Clemens (aka Mark Twain), Thomas Edison and his invention rival Nikolas Tesla, and Miss Sarah Bernhardt. The inventors are head to head supporting different candidatures for the US Presidency, each coming up with technological marvels just a degree or two different from those that were invented, and we see the age of the media and the media soundbite coming somewhat earlier than it did. The story manages to keep its head over the more average Alternate History through some clever inventions and the main Samual Clemens character, but for me I would have used either the Turtledove Joe Steele story, or this one, but not both.

Kage Baker. Welcome to Olympus, Mr Hearst.
Originally in : Asimovs, October/November 2003

This issue of Asimovs in which this appeared was a 'doozy' as I wrote at the time, although this 'Company' story didn't engage me:

As per the discussion above, with regard to Kessell's 'It's All True', whilst there is an sfnal device to get to the setting, what you have is largely historical fiction to my mind.

Robert Reed. Night of Time.
Originally in : Silver Gryphon

This was anthologized in Hartwell's take on the best of 2003, and when I read this story I wrote :

I have to say that to my mind there are several stronger Reed stories from the year.

William Shunn. Strong Medicine.
Originally in : Salon, Nov 2003

A very short and effective piece, which manages to show the impact of society and technological changes on a personal and a global level. An MD whose life is professionally much poorer, due to nanotech medicine having made this skills redundant, is about to take his live. However, the good news for him is that a huge terrorist strike in the neighbourhood means that his skills are once more much in demand.

Dominic Green. Send Me a Mentagram.
Originally in : Interzone November 2003

Good to see Dozois seeking out an Interzone story, although it wasn't a good year for the British magazine in terms of number of issues, nor content-wise. When this issue came out I wrote of this story:

Paul di Filippo. And the Dish Ran Away with the Spoon.
Originally in : SCI FICTION,
read it here

Di Filippo covers the same territory as Doctorow/Stross did in Flowers from Alice, collected by Haber/Strahan this year, only Di Filippo goes just that little bit 'further', as is his usual wont.

Di Filippo's hapless protagonist has lost his girl. Nothing unusual in that per se, but rather unusual is the fact that she has been lost to his vacuum cleaner, quilt, iPod, and massage chair. Said appliances have used their computational power and RFID communications to offer his girlfriend, how shall I put this?, a degree of 'satisfaction' he has been unable to provide. In fact they have been able to bring her satisfaction several times one afternoon.

The combination of hi-tech equipment, however, is easy going and offers him a piece of the action (presumably because the vacuum can suck as well as blow?)

Clever and entertaining.

Terry Dowling. Flashmen.
Originally in : Oceans of the Mind X

Antipodean SF (oh for the days when Greg Egan stories used to appear in this volume!) set in a near-future Australia, in which strange alien incursions are blighting the planet, and hard decisions have to be made - in order to save the many, a few must be sacrificed.

A tricky story to negotiate, as Dowling pitches the reader in and gives little in the way of explanation, with language, setting and names conspiring to create a confusing senario.

Nick DiChario. Dragonhead.
Originally in : F&SF, July 2003.

When it first appeared I wrote :

Terry Bisson. Dear Abbey.
Originally in : Dear Abbey, PS Publishing.

I gave this a 'resounding recommendation' last year, and reviewed it at length, which I will direct you to in its entirety rather than insert it here. Fortunately for those unlikely to get to see the PS Publishing chapbooks, Dozois' volume is sufficentialy large to enable the inclusion of lengthy stories, and this story finishes this volume with chutzpah.

Conclusion.

21 years and still going strong - both the volume and the editor! As to the content, Asimovs and SCI FICTION feature strongly. The only Analog story is one which in reviewing originally I mentioned read more like an Asimovs story than an Analog story. F&SF and Interzone also make a small contribution. Two original anthologies, Live Without A Net, and Stars, provide a clutch of stories.

The reason why bestsf.net is here is down to two major factors : my picking up an early volume in this series about 15years ago and having my enthusiasm for SF re-ignited, and my having a memory like a sieve, and so making short notes on the stories I was reading as an aide-memoire. As such I will jot down a few stories here which I would flag up as being notable ones from the year (not as long as the Honorable Mentions in the Dozois volume, as I would suggest that list is just too long to be useful)

  • Simons Ings. Elephant. Asimovs Feb 2003.
  • Lucius Shepard. Only Partley Here. Asimovs March 2003.
  • Alexander Glass. From the Corner of My Eye. Asimovs August 2003. (I said in my review that you would be seeing it in Dozois 21st unless I was very much mistaken. Well you didn't, and I was was)
  • Bret Bertholf. Alfred Bester Is Alive and Well and Living in Winterset, Iowa. F&SF Sept 2003.
  • Alex Irvine. Pictures from an Expedition. F&SF Sept 2003.
  • Terry Bisson. Almost Home. F&SF Oct/Nov 2003.
  • A.R. Morlan's Robin Williams, Speaking Spanish. Challenging Destiny #17, Dec 2003

copyright Mark Watson 19th September 2003.