Eliot Fintushel. The Grass and the Trees.
A return to the characters from Milo and Sylvie (Asimovs, March 2000 and Dozois' 18th), and a story which I would put forward for annual Dozoisification.
If I was of a more scientific bent I would probably analyse exactly what it is that makes a story a 'wowza' in my opinion, but I think that would spoil the fun. Certainly one element, which Fintushel has in spades, is letting the story develop without spelling everything out for the reader. This is of course quite different to Analog, for example, where authors evidently have to show their underpinning scientific paradigms in full.
Suffice to say, we have here a rich, suspenseful story, populated with fully fleshed (and often unlikeable) characters. Shape-shifting (with some degree of underpinning science) is the key element, and young Milo is being hunted by his sister.
Me, I'm off to re-read 'Milo and Sylvie'.
Conclusion.
A particularly strong issue, with Bateman/Traviss providing relatively bog-standard stories, and with Baxter (less so than the others), Ings, Grimsley and Fintushel providing a high quality.
10th February 2003
review copyright Mark Watson 2003